Crist: The great distaffers..

[RockHardTen1985]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

You throw around great like nerf balls.

Rachel and Zenyatta would have drowned Banshee Breeze.

Andy, based on what? Class, speed? I have BB pp's right here and it all looks pretty similar.

[The Indomitable DrugS]

Originally Posted by RockHardTen1985

Andy, based on what? Class, speed? I have BB pp's right here and it all looks pretty similar.

If it makes you feel any better ... I'd probably take Banshee Breeze and the points.



She always fired ... and even her 3 defeats at the end were ok. She got beat giving Beautiful Pleasure 11 pounds at 10 furlongs in slop for the first one - Keeper Hill rode a good rail at Keeneland while BB was wide in the Spinster loss - the BC Distaff loss at Gulfstream wasn't bad either.

[RockHardTen1985]

Originally Posted by The Indomitable DrugS

If it makes you feel any better ... I'd probably take Banshee Breeze and the points.



She always fired ... and even her 3 defeats at the end were ok. She got beat giving Beautiful Pleasure 11 pounds at 10 furlongs in slop for the first one - Keeper Hill rode a good rail at Keeneland while BB was wide in the Spinster loss - the BC Distaff loss at Gulfstream wasn't bad either.

THanks for posting this, I tryed 2 LOL.
Im kinda suprised a throwback like Serling would say Rachel and Z would have destroyed this one... I have a list of about 15 more just in the last 15 years... A thread is coming tomorrow.

[Gaining Ground]

was banshee breeze that much better than keeper hill? she was more consistent, but when both were on their game i dont think much separated them.

[The Indomitable DrugS]

Originally Posted by Gaining Ground

was banshee breeze that much better than keeper hill? she was more consistent, but when both were on their game i dont think much separated them.

WAY better than Keeper Hill!!

[Gaining Ground]

Originally Posted by The Indomitable DrugS

WAY better than Keeper Hill!!

careerwise, sure. and banshee breeze was a hell of a lot more consistent. she always showed up as you said. im just saying when they met, a neck separated them in the cca oaks and kentucky oaks. keeper hill finished in front of her in the mother goose and spinster. behind her in the personal ensign and bc distaff.

i just dont think they were that far off of each other when keeper hill was on her game. banshee breeze was always on her game.

[Indian Charlie]

Historically speaking, Banshee Breeze and Keeper Hill were both not much.

[The Indomitable DrugS]

Originally Posted by Gaining Ground

careerwise, sure. and banshee breeze was a hell of a lot more consistent. she always showed up as you said. im just saying when they met, a neck separated them in the cca oaks and kentucky oaks. keeper hill finished in front of her in the mother goose and spinster. behind her in the personal ensign and bc distaff.

i just dont think they were that far off of each other when keeper hill was on her game. banshee breeze was always on her game.

From the summer of their 3yo filly season on ... Banshee Breeze was vastly superior in every way.

The Spinster result was all about Keeneland's track bias. Banshee Breeze was 4 wide on both turns over a rail favoring race track .. Keeper Hill slipped up the rail and I believe was rail, rail on both turns ... Frankel praising it as one of the best rides.

Keeper Hill might be a 3 time Grade 1 winner .. but I think it's a huge insult to Banshee Breeze to say they had the same ability.

[RockHardTen1985]

Originally Posted by Gaining Ground

was banshee breeze that much better than keeper hill? she was more consistent, but when both were on their game i dont think much separated them.

You cant help yourself, you would argue anything I say, even if you agreed w/ me

[Gaining Ground]

Originally Posted by RockHardTen1985

You cant help yourself, you would argue anything I say, even if you agreed w/ me

it has nothing to do with you at all.

[Revidere]

Originally Posted by RockHardTen1985

THanks for posting this, I tryed 2 LOL.
Im kinda suprised a throwback like Serling would say Rachel and Z would have destroyed this one... I have a list of about 15 more just in the last 15 years... A thread is coming tomorrow.

Jersey Girl toyed with Banshee Breeze