Should Songbird retire?

[freddymo]

Originally Posted by ateamstupid

She was 2-5, loped along on the easiest of leads and still got tagged. There was nothing "awesome" about her performance. But this is who she is. She's a nice filly who always shows up, no matter the track, and runs average to below-average races for the Grade I level. She is entirely dependent on who she's facing and she lost to a clearly better horse yesterday, so now she's lost a step? Come on. She's good for the game and her connections have been great about showcasing her across the country, but the idea that she is or ever was some invincible Hall of Fame-caliber filly is just absurd.

EXACTLY. She obviously was much better at 2 and 3 or better said further along then her counterparts then at 4 and that isnt a knock its just reality. Even at her very best in both BC races she has NEVER run an all time great race. Frankly its a silly conversation anybody who is objective realizes she has never been much more then slightly above average G1 talent, effectively Ashado lite, a filly born in the right year where her competition was below typical average. I guess those calls/posts/tweets for her to face open male competition are mute now, that's a good thing. She would get destroyed by Diversify whom isnt a Graded stakes winner too date, She might lose by a pole. The great fillies that SB is allegedly on par would would swallow him for breakfast.

Forever Unbridled is OK she ran 2+ lengths further then SB as SB meandered uncontested and STILL she couldnt draw off. Why simply because she isnt that fast. FU runs by appt. only obviously has to have some soundness issues, if you watched her last 1/4 it was painful, and she still got to SB at 10f's she would have won by 6...Its Unbridled Forever for goodness sake not Personal Ensign Inside Information Azeri etc

have a heart folks...You really think she is a faster filly then Ashado who was another born in right year greatest evah

At 2:
Won Spinaway S. (G1), Demoiselle S. (G2), Schuylerville S. (G2)
2nd Breeders' Cup Juvenile Fillies (G1)
3rd Frizette S. (G1)
At 3:
Won Breeders' Cup Distaff (G1), Coaching Club American Oaks (G1), Kentucky Oaks (G1), Fair Grounds Oaks (G2), Cotillion H. (G2)
2nd Mother Goose S. (G1), Ashland S. (G1)
3rd Alabama S. (G1)

At 4:
Won Ogden Phipps H. (G1), Go For Wand H. (G1), Beldame S. (G1)
2nd Pimlico Distaff H. (G3)
3rd Breeders' Cup Distaff (G1)