Shared Belief

[cakes44]

Okay so clearly Perfect Drift and Lava Man are the arguing points. Maybe even throw Game On Dude in there. No one has argued the 9 other horses on my list, and that is only since 2003. How in the world is Commentator among the all-time greats if he might not even be among the top 10 since 2003 according to nearly everyone on here, which was my original point?

[NTamm1215]

Originally Posted by cakes44

Okay so clearly Perfect Drift and Lava Man are the arguing points. Maybe even throw Game On Dude in there. No one has argued the 9 other horses on my list, and that is only since 2003. How in the world is Commentator among the all-time greats if he might not even be among the top 10 since 2003 according to nearly everyone on here, which was my original point?

My post about Perfect Drift lacked his '03 running lines cause I could only screengrab so much. I'll post the rest tonight.

There's really only one person who has said that Commentator was an all-time great in this thread. Myself, and just about everyone else have offered that what Commentator lacked in durability he made up for in brilliance. He just didn't do it very often at all.

[RockHardTen1985]

Originally Posted by NTamm1215

My post about Perfect Drift lacked his '03 running lines cause I could only screengrab so much. I'll post the rest tonight.

There's really only one person who has said that Commentator was an all-time great in this thread. Myself, and just about everyone else have offered that what Commentator lacked in durability he made up for in brilliance. He just didn't do it very often at all.

This is not true Nick. I said since 2000.

[cakes44]

Originally Posted by RockHardTen1985

This is not true Nick. I said since 2000.

Originally Posted by RockHardTen1985 View Post
I agree with one thing in that post. Commentator is one of the GOAT.


"one of the GOAT" now means "one of the 13 greatest since 2000?"

[Indian Charlie]

Originally Posted by cakes44

Originally Posted by RockHardTen1985 View Post
I agree with one thing in that post. Commentator is one of the GOAT.


"one of the GOAT" now means "one of the 13 greatest since 2000?"

Well, duh.

[RockHardTen1985]

Originally Posted by cakes44

Originally Posted by RockHardTen1985 View Post
I agree with one thing in that post. Commentator is one of the GOAT.


"one of the GOAT" now means "one of the 13 greatest since 2000?"

Why not? I said one of. There are 100's of great horses.....

[Danzig]

Originally Posted by cakes44

Okay so clearly Perfect Drift and Lava Man are the arguing points. Maybe even throw Game On Dude in there. No one has argued the 9 other horses on my list, and that is only since 2003. How in the world is Commentator among the all-time greats if he might not even be among the top 10 since 2003 according to nearly everyone on here, which was my original point?

who in the world is calling commentator an all time great?

[Indian Charlie]

Originally Posted by Danzig

who in the world is calling commentator an all time great?

PG1985.

[Danzig]

Originally Posted by Indian Charlie

PG1985.

well that explains a lot.
i have him on ignore, so i missed that gem.