Orb Retired, to Stand at Claiborne in 2014

[Indian Charlie]

Originally Posted by freddymo

We are all guessing. To me it seems like a favor to Claiborne who's stallion roster has gone from a non factor to dominate in 5 years.

As hard as it is to pick winners on the track to bet...It is so much tougher to predict Stallion success. War Front? Tapit Malibu Moon? who thought these 3 could ever be the sports top producers. Malibu Moon had to be a billion to 1 to be a world class producer.

Malibu Moon displayed freakish ability in his brief career.

He has a great pedigree as well.

[randallscott35]

Originally Posted by Indian Charlie

Malibu Moon displayed freakish ability in his brief career.

He has a great pedigree as well.

Brief is the key word. Not freakish....Everything that is wrong with what we breed.

[Danzig]

Originally Posted by randallscott35

Brief is the key word. Not freakish....Everything that is wrong with what we breed.

you're conflating injury and unsoundness. he suffered an injury. he wasn't fragile, he got hurt. are you suggesting that if a horse suffers an injury before a certain amount of starts, he should be barred from standing at stud? if so, what's the magic number that delineates between sound and durable, and unsound and fragile?