Obama's stimulus was a massive failure and it didn't work

[Clip-Clop]

Originally Posted by Riot

You don't even know what the CBO is, do you? Yeah - the CBO is very well respected. Geeshus cripes.

You haven't posted one economist that disputes the CBO's data on jobs and GDP growth from the stimulus.

List one economist that says the stimulus didn't create that number of jobs, or didn't raise the GDP as it said it did.

You posted comments from 2010 - the stimulus effects were not even measurable at that time.

Got it, no.

You can not post the name of one single respected economist that supports the results of the stimulus as being a good thing.

[Riot]

Originally Posted by Clip-Clop

Got it, no.

You can not post the name of one single respected economist that supports the results of the stimulus as being a good thing.

Sorry - nice straw man, kinda desperate, but nobody is buying it.

Your challenge:

The CBO report of late 2011 measures the stimulus being a success via number of jobs created and GDP rise.

We're still waiting for you to post one economist saying, after that CBO report, that the CBO data was wrong and the stimulus was not a success - and provide any data to show why. You've posted zero.

Post one.

[Clip-Clop]

Originally Posted by Riot

Sorry - nice straw man, kinda desperate, but nobody is buying it.

Your challenge:

The CBO report of late 2011 measures the stimulus being a success via number of jobs created and GDP rise.

We're still waiting for you to post one economist saying, after that CBO report, that the CBO data was wrong and the stimulus was not a success - and provide any data to show why. You've posted zero.

Post one.

"Things like that oft-repeated canard, "the stimulus was an epic fail". Nope. 99.9% of economists around the world say, not at all, it worked. Yes, suck on that, Obama-haters. You may not "believe" in stimulus. But the stimulus worked, and that's a measurable and proven economic fact, verified by virtually every single independent economist."

Your words, not one mention of the CBO.
Please share which of the worlds independent economists you are referencing, 999 out of 1000 is a bold claim and should be easy to back up. It is time for you to actually defend one of your statements, or continue to just move the argument away from your actual words to some other made up version inside your head. Either way it is great theater for the rest of us.

[Riot]

Originally Posted by Clip-Clop

"Things like that oft-repeated canard, "the stimulus was an epic fail". Nope. 99.9% of economists around the world say, not at all, it worked. Yes, suck on that, Obama-haters. You may not "believe" in stimulus. But the stimulus worked, and that's a measurable and proven economic fact, verified by virtually every single independent economist."

Your words, not one mention of the CBO.
Please share which of the worlds independent economists you are referencing, 999 out of 1000 is a bold claim and should be easy to back up. It is time for you to actually defend one of your statements, or continue to just move the argument away from your actual words to some other made up version inside your head. Either way it is great theater for the rest of us.

You haven't posted one economist that, in 2012, disagrees that the stimulus worked, by arguing against the measurable facts of job creation and GDP growth.

Not one.

Okay - I'll be as shallow and superficial as you:

Did the stimulus work? A review of the nine best studies on the subject
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/...bibJ_blog.html

The Impact of the Recovery Act, In a Few Easy Charts
http://jaredbernsteinblog.com/the-re...w-easy-charts/

Hate It or Love It, the Stimulus Worked
http://prospect.org/article/hate-it-...timulus-worked

Don't Tell Anyone, but the Stimulus Worked
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/16/op...rked.html?_r=0

Why Obama's Stimulus Worked
http://www.usnews.com/opinion/blogs/...timulus-worked

Case closed: the stimulus worked
http://www.politico.com/news/stories/1111/68965.html


Economists saying the stimulus worked, with supporting data via published studies.

Feyrer and Sacerdote.

Chodorow-Reich, Feiveson, Liscow, and Woolston.

Wilson.

Congressional Budget Office.

Council of Economic Advisors.

Zandi and Blinder.

Oh and Reis.