American Idol, season 10

[somerfrost]

I really can't decide until I hear tonight's performances, both are good but neither can hold a candle to Haley in my opinion....but that the choice we have. I admit Lauren is rather big boned and carries a little weight especially for 16 but if you look at past winners, they tend to look a whole lot better after winning/competing on the show....take Jordin Sparks for example, she was heavy set when she won and when she performed a couple weeks ago, she has transformed into a smokin' hot chick.

[randallscott35]

Originally Posted by somerfrost

I really can't decide until I hear tonight's performances, both are good but neither can hold a candle to Haley in my opinion....but that the choice we have. I admit Lauren is rather big boned and carries a little weight especially for 16 but if you look at past winners, they tend to look a whole lot better after winning/competing on the show....take Jordin Sparks for example, she was heavy set when she won and when she performed a couple weeks ago, she has transformed into a smokin' hot chick.

We aren't voting based on weight here people. This isn't an eating contest. Her voice is hands down better than Scotty's and I like country music.

Very few fat entertainers end up being stars.

That's why the judges are talking about the total package. Being skinny and attractive is part of it.

[randallscott35]

Originally Posted by Coach Pants

Very few fat entertainers end up being stars.

That's why the judges are talking about the total package. Being skinny and attractive is part of it.

Look at Jennifer Hudson? Get her a trainer, she'll be fine. She isn't Romans.

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by randallscott35

We aren't voting based on weight here people. This isn't an eating contest. Her voice is hands down better than Scotty's and I like country music.

I agree, just citing Jordin Sparks to prove a point...once these folks sign contracts they tend to fit into the mold. Jennifer is another example, hell...she does weight loss commercials. A 16 year old will naturally undergo body changes as she matures. Hard for me to judge their voices as the are quite different, I've always thought the best two were Haley and James, and I continue to believe that all four will be successful, which will be the biggest star? I have no idea.

[alysheba4]

that show sucks.....the dude with the dumbo ears was best.

[randallscott35]

Umm, Lauren won tonight. End of story.

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by randallscott35

Umm, Lauren won tonight. End of story.

I agree 100%, Lauren won by a mile...to quote Steven, "sorry Scotty", she was outstanding and Scotty average. We will see if the army of teenybopper girls votes for Scotty regardless of performances.

[randallscott35]

Looks like Scotty won...Now I don't have to watch.

http://www.webpronews.com/scotty-mcc...drudge-2011-05