12 way shake for Made For Magic ($62,500)

[Indian Charlie]

Originally Posted by Rupert Pupkin

That is exactly the point. That is why it's silly for people to measure how good she is based on her final times and winning margins.

Let me know when she doesn't face cheap claimers or wildly overrated turf horses that are running on synthetics.

[Rupert Pupkin]

Originally Posted by Indian Charlie

Let me know when she doesn't face cheap claimers or wildly overrated turf horses that are running on synthetics.

How overrated could Gio Ponti be? He's won five Grade I stakes races. Any horse that's won 5 grade I races has got to be a pretty good horse.

And we've seen time and time again that most of these turf horses can run well on synthetic tracks, so I don't think you can say that Gio Ponti isn't good on synthetic tracks.

[letswastemoney]

[CSC]

Originally Posted by Rupert Pupkin

How overrated could Gio Ponti be? He's won five Grade I stakes races. Any horse that's won 5 grade I races has got to be a pretty good horse.

And we've seen time and time again that most of these turf horses can run well on synthetic tracks, so I don't think you can say that Gio Ponti isn't good on synthetic tracks.

The horse's she beat in the classic were just awful, only 2 that have come back to race in 2010 have yet to win a grade 1. Twice Over, Awesome Gem, Rip Van Winkle, Gio Ponti have all come back to win grade 1's this year. Which translates into a fat 67% of the horses she has run against in the Classic that are still running today have won grade 1 wins thus far. Yep it's brutal.

[The Indomitable DrugS]

Originally Posted by CSC

The horse's she beat in the classic were just awful, only 2 that have come back to race in 2010 have yet to win a grade 1. Twice Over, Awesome Gem, Rip Van Winkle, Gio Ponti have all come back to win grade 1's this year. Which translates into a fat 67% of the horses she has run against in the Classic that are still running today have won grade 1 wins thus far. Yep it's brutal.

Great, 3 turf horses and the ancient grinder Awesome Gem.

It was nice to see Gio Ponti finally win a stretch duel for a change in his Grade 1 ... even though the 2nd place finisher was defeated in a race he was claimed for 35K out of last time out.



Yeah, claim a New York bred for 35K, watch it get beat, enter in a Grade 1 stakes next out and almost win. Good plan. Props to trainer Naipual Chatterpaul for having the brains to realize the turf horses here suck balls.

Rip Van Winkle was on the fence to even run in the Classic because of a foot issue. He did run - and ran like an utter cripple .. he beat almost no one and even Mine That Bird finished a huge margin in front of him ... the same MTB that ran dead last over the same track in the BC Juvie the prior year and was later soundly crushed by Gitano Hernando .. some phony from Europe with a Latino Prison sounding name who made a mockery of the Goodwood Stakes field.

Awesome Gem came East and ran on dirt - he got smoked at Charles Town and smoked at Lone Star

[Indian Charlie]

Originally Posted by CSC

The horse's she beat in the classic were just awful, only 2 that have come back to race in 2010 have yet to win a grade 1. Twice Over, Awesome Gem, Rip Van Winkle, Gio Ponti have all come back to win grade 1's this year. Which translates into a fat 67% of the horses she has run against in the Classic that are still running today have won grade 1 wins thus far. Yep it's brutal.

Holy cow you are dumb.

[NTamm1215]

Originally Posted by CSC

The horse's she beat in the classic were just awful, only 2 that have come back to race in 2010 have yet to win a grade 1. Twice Over, Awesome Gem, Rip Van Winkle, Gio Ponti have all come back to win grade 1's this year. Which translates into a fat 67% of the horses she has run against in the Classic that are still running today have won grade 1 wins thus far. Yep it's brutal.

Imagine that, Rip, Gio Ponti and Twice Over won GIs on their preferred surface this year! Since when has 4 of 7 equaled 67%?

NT

[Rupert Pupkin]

Originally Posted by CSC

The horse's she beat in the classic were just awful, only 2 that have come back to race in 2010 have yet to win a grade 1. Twice Over, Awesome Gem, Rip Van Winkle, Gio Ponti have all come back to win grade 1's this year. Which translates into a fat 67% of the horses she has run against in the Classic that are still running today have won grade 1 wins thus far. Yep it's brutal.

That's not important unless every horse in the field comes back to win a Grade I and even that's not imprtant unless each Grade I is a tough Grade I. I can't belive you didn't know that. And Gio Ponti's Grade I does not mean anything since he beat a claimer. Never mind Gio Ponti's other four Grade I wins last year. He's obviously not a very goood horse despite the fact that he's won five Grade 1's.

[the_fat_man]

Originally Posted by Rupert Pupkin

That's not important unless every horse in the field comes back to win a Grade I and even that's not imprtant unless each Grade I is a tough Grade I. I can't belive you didn't know that. And Gio Ponti's Grade I does not mean anything since he beat a claimer. Never mind Gio Ponti's other four Grade I wins last year. He's obviously not a very goood horse despite the fact that he's won five Grade 1's.

He's just here to incite. He's taken up the torch from the Beyerites/DRFites. He's even at the point where he's using POLY BEYERS in his arguments.

ha ha ha

Yeah, I take much of what he writes seriously.

Their HOTY got her ass kicked. Their FAST, 138 Beyer, best horse in the country got his ass kicked after setting slow fractions. And, they're still here continually having a go at a horse that's UNDEFEATED and won the CLASSIC last year --- while their horses either stayed home or REFUSED to gate.

Perfect example of taking the offensive when you don't have a leg to stand on.

And people are still BITING.

And the dude wonders, actually PUBLICLY MOANS, about PID using some know nothing babe instead of him for prerace analysis. Wonder why that is?

[ateamstupid]

Originally Posted by the_fat_man

Their HOTY got her ass kicked.

Funny, I thought she was everybody's HOY. Since she actually won the award and all. And I know it kills you.

[Sightseek]

Originally Posted by the_fat_man

He's just here to incite. He's taken up the torch from the Beyerites/DRFites. He's even at the point where he's using POLY BEYERS in his arguments.

ha ha ha

Yeah, I take much of what he writes seriously.

Their HOTY got her ass kicked. Their FAST, 138 Beyer, best horse in the country got his ass kicked after setting slow fractions. And, they're still here continually having a go at a horse that's UNDEFEATED and won the CLASSIC last year --- while their horses either stayed home or REFUSED to gate.

Perfect example of taking the offensive when you don't have a leg to stand on.

And people are still BITING.

And the dude wonders, actually PUBLICLY MOANS, about PID using some know nothing babe instead of him for prerace analysis. Wonder why that is?

I laughed.

[The Indomitable DrugS]

Originally Posted by the_fat_man

And the dude wonders, actually PUBLICLY MOANS, about PID using some know nothing babe instead of him for prerace analysis. Wonder why that is?

I don't know, maybe because I took down the whole pool in the Pick 3 ending in the 4th race today?

[GPK]

Originally Posted by The Indomitable DrugS

I don't know, maybe because I took down the whole pool in the Pick 3 ending in the 4th race today?

Yeah, but he gave out a $29 exacta for a $1 today

[Rupert Pupkin]

Originally Posted by The Indomitable DrugS

I don't know, maybe because I took down the whole pool in the Pick 3 ending in the 4th race today?

Hitting a $1,200 Pick 3 isn't bad but I doubt they would hire you based on that.

[DaTruth]

Originally Posted by Rupert Pupkin

That's not important unless every horse in the field comes back to win a Grade I and even that's not imprtant unless each Grade I is a tough Grade I. I can't belive you didn't know that. And Gio Ponti's Grade I does not mean anything since he beat a claimer. Never mind Gio Ponti's other four Grade I wins last year. He's obviously not a very goood horse despite the fact that he's won five Grade 1's.

Aside from Awesome Gem, how many of the others have won a Grade 1 or Group 1 over a synthetic surface.

[DaTruth]

If a single stakes race matters that much, then Garthorn is the greatest horse since 1986. In the 1986 Met Mile, he defeated the defending BC Classic champion, the 1986 BC Sprint winner, the 1986 BC Distaff winner and Horse of the Year, and the 1986 Champion Older Horse.

[Revidere]

Originally Posted by DaTruth

If a single stakes race matters that much, then Garthorn is the greatest horse since 1986. In the 1986 Met Mile, he defeated the defending BC Classic champion, the 1986 BC Sprint winner, the 1986 BC Distaff winner and Horse of the Year, and the 1986 Champion Older Horse.

Did someone say Garthorn and the 1986 Met Mile????



The Vanquished:

[Rupert Pupkin]

Originally Posted by DaTruth

Aside from Awesome Gem, how many of the others have won a Grade 1 or Group 1 over a synthetic surface.

There were several in there. Just off the top of my head there was Richard's Kid, Einstein, and Colonel John. So that means there were 4 including Awesome Gem.