7/31 (DMR): Wickerr S. (Colonel John return)

[The Indomitable DrugS]

Kind of an odd spot for his return.

[CSC]

Being naturally suspicious, I'm suspicious.

[King Glorious]

If they want to get to the Pacific Classic, I think it's perfect.

[eajinabi]

colonel john = over rated

[King Glorious]

Originally Posted by eajinabi

colonel john = over rated

Depends on your perspective. If you are talking about how good is he on a national level, that's debatable. He's just like Pioneerof the Nile. Both were the dominant 3yo in California leading up to the TC. Pioneer, did somewhat validate himself with a second in the Derby. So did Colonel John with a win in the Travers. If your opinion of him/them were that they were the best 3yo in California, I don't see how they are overrated. If your opinion of him was that he was a top five 3yo nationally, then maybe you have a point.

[Indian Charlie]

Originally Posted by King Glorious

He's just like Pioneerof the Nile. Both were the dominant 3yo in California leading up to the TC.

POTN was 10x the horse of Colonel Tiago. Not that that is saying a lot, of course.

Don't forget, Tiago John ran against the worst crop of 3yos in all of human history. Past, present or future.

[King Glorious]

Originally Posted by Indian Charlie

POTN was 10x the horse of Colonel Tiago. Not that that is saying a lot, of course.

Don't forget, Tiago John ran against the worst crop of 3yos in all of human history. Past, present or future.

He might have but he still was the dominant 3yo in California that year and he did go to Saratoga and be the best of that horrible crop. Nobody is saying that he ranks with the best 3yos in the history of the sport. But in relation to his group, he was among the best.

[CSC]

Originally Posted by King Glorious

If they want to get to the Pacific Classic, I think it's perfect.

11 career races, no apparent turf pedigree, off a 7 month layoff and supposedly returning in a career first time try in a turf stk. Maybe they are praying for rain...

[cakes44]

Originally Posted by CSC

11 career races, no apparent turf pedigree, off a 7 month layoff and supposedly returning in a career first time try in a turf stk. Maybe they are praying for rain...

You don't think they are licking their lips for the 3rd/4th place $$ they'll get from an $85,000 race?

[CSC]

Originally Posted by cakes44

You don't think they are licking their lips for the 3rd/4th place $$ they'll get from an $85,000 race?

I laughed.

[King Glorious]

Originally Posted by CSC

11 career races, no apparent turf pedigree, off a 7 month layoff and supposedly returning in a career first time try in a turf stk. Maybe they are praying for rain...

If they are looking for the best possible spot for a win, then I would tend to agree with you. But sometimes, the objective is to finally get a race into a horse and get the conditioning you need to move to the next step. Turf racing is not as hard on horses as dirt racing is (still getting used to this junk track) and a mile race in a decent field will do a lot more than just coming straight into the Pacific Classic off of works and is a lot less taxing than the San Diego Hcp would be. Also, if he was a horse that was primarily a dirt horse, I think the transition to grass might be more difficult. But not for a dominant synthetic horse.

[CSC]

Originally Posted by King Glorious

If they are looking for the best possible spot for a win, then I would tend to agree with you. But sometimes, the objective is to finally get a race into a horse and get the conditioning you need to move to the next step. Turf racing is not as hard on horses as dirt racing is (still getting used to this junk track) and a mile race in a decent field will do a lot more than just coming straight into the Pacific Classic off of works and is a lot less taxing than the San Diego Hcp would be. Also, if he was a horse that was primarily a dirt horse, I think the transition to grass might be more difficult. But not for a dominant synthetic horse.

Given he did win The Travers last year, I would have thought a more abitious approach would have been in the offing. It's not like he wouldn't have options in either the Whitney or The Pacific Classic to choose from. Really Harty could separate Well Armed and C. John without much difficulty. Again it raises an eyebrow with me and it may signal that all is not well with him, he reportedly is getting over an illness this spring, anyway these are reasonable questions any decent handicapper should ask, rather than digest the convienient turf to dirt 'prep' race angle we are supposedly to believe as something that is the norm.

[Bobby Fischer]

We think that Becrux and Prussian figure in this salty affair.











just kidding ( i just wanted to say "we" ) , but I do like those two. Get Funky is mildly interesting. Same with the NZ import.