ahh..the good ole days..

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by Danzig

not saying it's tit for tat; also don't believe that if we treat their prisoners well, that they will reply in kind. what i am saying is that we don't need to be breaking any of our own laws while fighting terrorism.

These arent US citizens and it isnt US soil. If you didnt think the analogy fit why did you state it?

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by hi_im_god

http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/200506/budiansky


"Since the prison scandals broke, many old hands in the business have pointed out that abusing prisoners is not simply illegal and immoral; it is also remarkably ineffective."

"The torture of suspects [at Abu Ghraib] did not lead to any useful intelligence information being extracted," says James Corum, a professor at the U.S. Army Command and General Staff College and the author of a forthcoming book on counterinsurgency warfare. "The abusers couldn't even use the old 'ends justify the means' argument, because in the end there was nothing to show but a tremendous propaganda defeat for the United States."

Corum, who recently retired as a lieutenant colonel after twenty-eight years in the Army and Reserves, mostly in military intelligence, says that Moran's philosophy has repeatedly been affirmed in subsequent wars large and small. "Know their language, know their culture, and treat the captured enemy as a human being" is how Corum sums up Moran's enduring lesson."

Though we dont know for sure i would guess that the "old hands" that aren't trying to sell books may not agree with Corum. I would like to know exactly what wars small and large he is referring to.