What's your take?

[jwkniska]

not in any way, shape nor form. look what's happened to the other sports where things are voted on by fans.

screwed up and basically ruined baseball, hockey and nba's all-star games (all a popularity contest now... not who's the best player that year), also the nfl pro-bowl's the same way.... let alone college football and the stupid human polls there (where's the playoff?).

eclipse awards should be voted on by the people that know the situation the best... the horsemen (owners, trainers and jocks).