HOF First Time Nominees...cough, cough

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by SCUDSBROTHER

Yea,for a punchin' Judy lover like you.You complain that Garvey didn't hit enough home runs for a 1st baseman,but this 1st baseman hit less than 100 HR.This player had very little impact on winning games.Much less(incredibly less) than Garvey did.Yea,if nobody was on base with 2 outs,then Carew would punch the ball through the infield.Big fkn deal.He played in SOCAL.I saw him plenty.He was useless.You're right about one thing.It's all about math to you.Punchin' Judy guys look good with math,but in reality=useless.The Marlin's Cabrera is about 20 times as likely to have an impact on a game than Carew,Boggs,Gwynn.What do they have together? 1 ring?

You are right...that Ty Cobb was a piece of **** too.


Garvey didn't hit many HR's for a 1st baseman that played 18years.

I guess Ted Williams was no good either because he won no rings. Come on this is worse than PG1985.