HOF First Time Nominees...cough, cough

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by SCUDSBROTHER

1974-ML-AS MVP1st at something....notice the word "most"
1974-NL-MVP1st at something....notice the word "most"
1978-ML-AS MVP1st at something....notice the word "most"
1978-NLCS MVP1st at something....notice the word "most"
1981-ML-Roberto Clemente Award
1984-ML-Lou Gehrig Memorial Award
1984-NLCS MVP1st at something....notice the word "most"

The above accomplishments should of got him in.He should of taken Tony Perez' spot.Garvey liked to hump too much(that's why he isn't in...it's not because of what he didn't do on the field.)Before he got caught humping,people voted him to start allstar games 9 times.....Best 1st baseman 9 times in his league,but his accomplishments aren't enough?

Not the best 1st baseman just the one lucky enough to play in the 2nd biggest media market in an era where there were very few top 1st baseman.

[SCUDSBROTHER]

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

Not the best 1st baseman just the one lucky enough to play in the 2nd biggest media market in an era where there were very few top 1st baseman.

I told you to PLEASE give me names that should've started in front of him in those ALL STAR GAMES.If you disagreed with him starting ,then you should have the alternates you wanted back then.