American Idol Week 3: A Horseplayer's Perspective

[ArlJim78]

Originally Posted by brianwspencer

Or Britney Spears.

A hot mess is a hot mess any way you cut it.

OH man, my nomination for good true line of the night!

[Samarta]

They were all brutal last night....all of them....I think they should make an executive decision and do away with that 6 and 6 crap...in fact, I found it interesting that the judges last night were basically saying that....they felt that only 4 should go on....I just hope that Sanjaya kid goes home.....hell I bet there are some better voices than that on this site....

[brianwspencer]

Perhaps tonight will give us more to talk about.

I didn't realize it would be so little fun when we all agreed that they were bad

At least tonight Somer and AJ can apologize for Antonella and make more excuses for her again after she butchers her third straight song.

[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by brianwspencer

Perhaps tonight will give us more to talk about.

I didn't realize it would be so little fun when we all agreed that they were bad

At least tonight Somer and AJ can apologize for Antonella and make more excuses for her again after she butchers her third straight song.

Well Brian, can you honestly say that more than 4 of the guys deserve to go on? If Antonella gets voted off this week, there will be at least two male singers of lesser ability who make it...same with any of the top 8 women. We will see what happens tonight but it is a shame that they don't take the top 12 regardless of sex....this year it would probably have been 9-3 or 10-2 women.

[Buffymommy]

After last nights performances, I say Both Chrises, Blake and Sundance move on. Sorry, Phil. I liked you but ya let me down last night and I do love that song you did, but he sucked.

Blake-Boring but sounded OK.

Sanjaya-his girlie ass needs to go home. Give Farrah Fawcett back her hair on your way out.

Sundance-OK, but not great.

Chris R.-Good, but was better last week.

Jared-better than Sanjaya, but that isn't saying much.

Brandon-ok, but not great. On a positive note, you didn't try and sing Cyndi so that was a great improvement.

Phil-Love that song, but you butchered it Phil. Sorry. I liked you until last night.

Chris S.-Probably the best of last night. I like this guy. Seems to be humbling a bit from his first week of Simon bashing. He is figuring out that he needs to be humble to make it.

All and all the guys DID NOT impress.

[ArlJim78]

Originally Posted by brianwspencer

Perhaps tonight will give us more to talk about.

I didn't realize it would be so little fun when we all agreed that they were bad

At least tonight Somer and AJ can apologize for Antonella and make more excuses for her again after she butchers her third straight song.

All l I can say Brian is get ready for Antonella in the final 12. All she has to do is not perform horribly. she's got a builtin fan base that will be calling in. She did what she had to do, and that's establish name recognition.

[brianwspencer]

Originally Posted by ArlJim78

All l I can say Brian is get ready for Antonella in the final 12. All she has to do is not perform horribly. she's got a builtin fan base that will be calling in. She did what she had to do, and that's establish name recognition.

I know. That's what's so scary about the whole thing. She could really make it far even though she ranks in the bottom 1/4 of the people left.

We'll see.

Originally Posted by somerfrost

Well Brian, can you honestly say that more than 4 of the guys deserve to go on? If Antonella gets voted off this week, there will be at least two male singers of lesser ability who make it...same with any of the top 8 women. We will see what happens tonight but it is a shame that they don't take the top 12 regardless of sex....this year it would probably have been 9-3 or 10-2 women.

Oh, no way, there are MAYBE four guys who deserve to go on. I think the Chrises, Blake, and either Brandon or Sundance should be the ones moving on, at MOST.

The girls are towering above them in every way. Really, they don't have many weaknesses left. Haley and Antonella are the only two left who are undeserving in any way of making the top 12. Gina is still on the bubble, her performance tonight should really determine whether or not she deserves to be there. She hasn't really proven herself entirely yet, but she's got a clear raw talent advantage over those other two girls.

They should just skip the antics and boot those two girls, bring those four guys and let's just go from the top 10. The rest is filler right now.