Idol's Antonella Barba, "provocative" pics on net

[brianwspencer]

Originally Posted by MaTH716

The bottom line about last years winner, was that he was really able to sing!

Oh this is going to be a long season discussing this with you.

Bottom line he could sing? He was MAYBE worthy of making the final six. It almost made me stop watching the show because I was so incredulous that he won the competition.

And that opinion has been completely reaffirmed by the fact that his album completely tanked compared to those who didn't take home the title last season.

[MaTH716]

Originally Posted by brianwspencer

Oh this is going to be a long season discussing this with you.

Bottom line he could sing? He was MAYBE worthy of making the final six. It almost made me stop watching the show because I was so incredulous that he won the competition.

And that opinion has been completely reaffirmed by the fact that his album completely tanked compared to those who didn't take home the title last season.

For the record. I thought Chirs was hands down the best singer last season and arguably the best one in the six seasons. But I like rock music the best. At first I liked Taylor, but at the end I wanted to see him get whacked Soprano style! That whole personality versus singing contest came in to play. Taylor had more than Katherine and it helped him that Katherine wasn't that good on the final night. I look foward to discussing this season with you guys. Or at least until Kentucky Derby time!

[brianwspencer]

Originally Posted by MaTH716

For the record. I thought Chirs was hands down the best singer last season and arguably the best one in the six seasons. But I like rock music the best. At first I liked Taylor, but at the end I wanted to see him get whacked Soprano style! That whole personality versus singing contest came in to play. Taylor had more than Katherine and it helped him that Katherine wasn't that good on the final night. I look foward to discussing this season with you guys. Or at least until Kentucky Derby time!

I decided I'm going to blog about it on my blog during the season with notes and all that corny bullcrap from every performance night. i'll be cross posting everything in an american idol thread which i hope will distance itself from porno pictures

i'm sure it's going to be fun, because even my partner and i can't agree on what's good and what's bad....but i don't think he knows very much about music and what's good or bad. so there is some comfort in that.

case in point. he noticed NOTHING wrong with the first half minute of phil stacey's performance on tuesday night. NOTHING AT ALL. Except that I pointed out that those thirty seconds were without a doubt the most wretched thirty consecutive seconds of any performer on either night.

[MaTH716]

Originally Posted by brianwspencer

I decided I'm going to blog about it on my blog during the season with notes and all that corny bullcrap from every performance night. i'll be cross posting everything in an american idol thread which i hope will distance itself from porno pictures

i'm sure it's going to be fun, because even my partner and i can't agree on what's good and what's bad....but i don't think he knows very much about music and what's good or bad. so there is some comfort in that.

case in point. he noticed NOTHING wrong with the first half minute of phil stacey's performance on tuesday night. NOTHING AT ALL. Except that I pointed out that those thirty seconds were without a doubt the most wretched thirty consecutive seconds of any performer on either night.

Agreed about Phil the other night. It started off like a train wreck. Looking
forward to the American Idol recap thread.