Derby Aftermath

[richard burch]

Originally Posted by Kitan

Neglecting any others that were definitely missed, I don't think an average of a positive test every 16 months can be considered "light".

Would Irish racing let Aidan O'Brien get away with a positive test every 16 months for 40 years? No.
Would GB racing let Sir Michael Stoute get away with a positive test every 16 months for 40 years? No.
Would Australian racing let Gai Waterhouse get away with a positive test every 16 months for 40 years? No.

As ADJMK said, after 30+ positive tests, you lose the benefit of the doubt, even if completely innocent this time. Even if it was contamination from e.g. a groom, at the end of the day it is his racing stable and he is responsible for all contact made between workers and horses. It's not a one off "mistake".

Well then that is a punishment problem within the sport itself in the U.S. If you let them off with a slap on the wrist they will keep doing it. 3 Strikes and ban them for life, fine with me.