All-time favorite Preakness?

[The Indomitable DrugS]

The 89 Preakness with EG and SS was the most exciting Preakness ever.

The best performance would be a toss-up between Spectacular Bid and Secretariat---both winning in awesome fashion inspite of unfavorable trips.

The former being floated way out by Cordero through the first turn and down the back stretch run---and the latter making an eye-catching premature move and sustaining it---both winning in excellent time (if you believe the timing error was authentic in Big Red's case)