Mel Gibson's Anti-Semetic Tirade

[Danzig]

Originally Posted by Rupert Pupkin

I was half-way kidding. But in all seriousness, how could there have been any atheist crusades? Were there any parts of the world where the atheists had enough power or enough people to go on a crusade?

lol i kinda figured your comment was a bit joking.

but i somehow don't see 'atheist' and 'crusade' going together. funny tho that the pope who started all the crusading spirit somehow convinced a lot of pious people that killing infidels was fine just fine, and god wanted them to do it.

[Ruffian2]

Originally Posted by whorstman

If most people followed the "Golden Rule", that would pretty much cover it.

"He who has the gold makes the rules," right??

[Smooth Operator]

Originally Posted by Ruffian

"He who has the gold makes the rules," right??

I'm keeping an eye on you.

[alysheba4]

the south park episode featuring mel was genius.

[GenuineRisk]

Originally Posted by alysheba4

the south park episode featuring mel was genius.

True 'dat. I think you can find the Mel Gibson part of it on youtube.com.

[Scurlogue Champ]

Originally Posted by Rupert Pupkin

Gibson is hardly a great spokesman for Christians, not after those shameful comments. His anti-semetic comments are disgraceful. The comments are incredibly ignorant too. As a Christian, I am ashamed of his comments. I guess his comments are not that shocking though considering that his father thinks that the Holocaust never happened.
If there's one thing that I can't figure out, it's Christians that don't like Jews. If you are a Christian, then your religion is based on the Bible. In the Bible, God says that Jews are his people. So how could a Christian dislike Jews? That would basically be going against your own religion. How would a Christian expect to have God's favor if they dislike God's people?
One thing funny about Gibson's commnets is that his agent of 20 years is Jewish.

I don't think that his father thinks that the holocaust never happened.

What he said is that the number of jews killed seems to keep going up.

4 million, to 8 million, to 12 million, etc....

Basically he was saying that the jews were using the holocaust as a means for advancement. Which is a whole other can of worms.

But I don't think that Mel or his Father ever absolutely denied the holocaust.

History is always up for debate.

[Rupert Pupkin]

Originally Posted by moodwalker

I don't think that his father thinks that the holocaust never happened.

What he said is that the number of jews killed seems to keep going up.

4 million, to 8 million, to 12 million, etc....

Basically he was saying that the jews were using the holocaust as a means for advancement. Which is a whole other can of worms.

But I don't think that Mel or his Father ever absolutely denied the holocaust.

History is always up for debate.

You may be right about that. I recently read that Mel had said in an interview that his father did not deny the Holocaust but just said it was exagerrated. I don't know if that is true or not but I know that that is what Mel claims.

Either way, I think it is pretty obvious that his father is anti-semetic. Who, other than an anti-semite would be bickering about whether it was 4 million or 6 million Jews killed in concentration camps? That would be like me saying that John Wayne Gasey is not as bad a guy as everyone says. I don't think he killed as many people as they say. They say he killed 50 people but I think he only killed 35 people.
By the way, I don't think there is much debate as to how many Jews died in the Holocaust. I think that historians are pretty confident that the number is about 6 million. In the years right after the Holocaust, it may have taken them a while to come up with a figure. Mel was claiming that his dad claims that they originally said the number was 12 million and then they lowered it to 10 million and then 6 million. I don't know if that's true or not but even if it is true it doesn't mean that anyone was fudging the numbers. It just means that it took a while for them to figure out how many people died. Even with 9/11 and the World Trade Center, it took them several months to figure out how many people died. I think the number ended up being about 3000 but they originally had no idea what the number was. A few days after 9/11, there were all kinds of numbers out there. Some people thought the number was well over 10,000.

By the way, former KKK member David Duke is another guy who says the Holocaust was greatly exagerrated.

[Scurlogue Champ]

Originally Posted by Rupert Pupkin

You may be right about that. I recently read that Mel had said in an interview that his father did not deny the Holocaust but just said it was exagerrated. I don't know if that is true or not but I know that that is what Mel claims.

Either way, I think it is pretty obvious that his father is anti-semetic. Who, other than an anti-semite would be bickering about whether it was 4 million or 6 million Jews killed in concentration camps? That would be like me saying that John Wayne Gasey is not as bad a guy as everyone says. I don't think he killed as many people as they say. They say he killed 50 people but I think he only killed 35 people.
By the way, I don't think there is much debate as to how many Jews died in the Holocaust. I think that historians are pretty confident that the number is about 6 million. In the years right after the Holocaust, it may have taken them a while to come up with a figure. Mel was claiming that his dad claims that they originally said the number was 12 million and then they lowered it to 10 million and then 6 million. I don't know if that's true or not but even if it is true it doesn't mean that anyone was fudging the numbers. It just means that it took a while for them to figure out how many people died. Even with 9/11 and the World Trade Center, it took them several months to figure out how many people died. I think the number ended up being about 3000 but they originally had no idea what the number was. A few days after 9/11, there were all kinds of numbers out there. Some people thought the number was well over 10,000.

By the way, former KKK member David Duke is another guy who says the Holocaust was greatly exagerrated.

Well, it is definitely another topic totally why his dad would say that the numbers were exaggerated or fudged. There is always debate about everything, regardless of who you believe to be correct.

I personally don't much care either way, I was just saying that his dad didn't say that there was no such thing as the holocaust.

But you are correct, he is an anti-semite. And I guess this can be categorically said due to some of his published quotes.

To answer your question as to who, other than an anti-semite, might be debating the number killed? I would have to say historians might be debating it. Are you asserting that by even questioning matters concerning the history of the jewish people, you are automatically an anti-semite?

You winding it up by making sure that you mention David Duke was a nice touch. That guy is whacko, but in no way represents everyone who researches the holocaust.

[Rupert Pupkin]

Originally Posted by moodwalker

Well, it is definitely another topic totally why his dad would say that the numbers were exaggerated or fudged. There is always debate about everything, regardless of who you believe to be correct.

I personally don't much care either way, I was just saying that his dad didn't say that there was no such thing as the holocaust.

But you are correct, he is an anti-semite. And I guess this can be categorically said due to some of his published quotes.

To answer your question as to who, other than an anti-semite, might be debating the number killed? I would have to say historians might be debating it. Are you asserting that by even questioning matters concerning the history of the jewish people, you are automatically an anti-semite?

You winding it up by making sure that you mention David Duke was a nice touch. That guy is whacko, but in no way represents everyone who researches the holocaust.

I'm not aware that there is a debate about the numbers. The only number I've ever heard is 6 million. I don't think there's any debate amongst credible historians. I've never heard anyone credible dispute that number.

The President of Iran disputes it, if you consider him credible. LOL. Actually I think that guy denies that it ever happened.

[whorstman]

Originally Posted by alysheba4

the south park episode featuring mel was genius.

HAHA it was on last night...

"KAPLAHHHH!!!......KAPLAHHHHHHH!!!!"

300 million at the box office Kyle.....Mel Gibson Kyle.......Mel Gibson.