All-time Top 12 seasons by a QB

[King Glorious]

There's no question in my mind that I'd take Brady over Manning. None.

[The Indomitable DrugS]

Originally Posted by King Glorious

There's no question in my mind that I'd take Brady over Manning. None.

I'd take Manning in a heartbeat. But...

Pre-injury or right now?

Brady got outplayed by Matt Ryan yesterday. Even the team of Brady adoring commentators (Buck and Aikman) said so much throughout the game.

He's consistantly missing wide open guys badly.. though he has settled down very nicely late in the 4th quarter in those two wins.

[docicu3]

Originally Posted by The Indomitable DrugS

I'd take Manning in a heartbeat. But...

Pre-injury or right now?

Brady got outplayed by Matt Ryan yesterday. Even the team of Brady adoring commentators (Buck and Aikman) said so much throughout the game.

He's consistantly missing wide open guys badly.. though he has settled down very nicely late in the 4th quarter in those two wins.

Like many before him, Carson of Cinn., most recently comes to mind. It will take Brady at least a year and perhaps 2 or 3 before he consistently throws like he did before the injury. Part head, part heart, part maturing graft, part persistent pain and weakness in the leg. The four grafts that anchor his new AC in his knee will not be what they can be until at least next football year. Don't underestimate how much healthy legs are essential to strong pinpoint passing. And because it feels good one down don't think it's the same feeling for every down. He'll get better with time but he is not really Brady yet.....and no doubt BB knows this and will adjust on the fly accordingly. Patience Drugs....