Who wins Horse of the Year?

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

I was embarrassed for the game last year when they gave the HoY to a horse based on "everybody gets a trophy", 3rd grade logic. I'm ashamed for the sport if a glorified grade 3 type like Game on Dude gets the HoY for winning the 2 most watered down versions of the Big Cap and Goodwood in recent memory (he barely beat Setsuko and Awesome Gem) and a 2nd place finish to Drosselmeyer.

Horseracing in 2011 has become a joke

Someone has to win. Horse racing in 2011 is what it was. Don't think I'd call it a joke. May not have been the most talented crop ever. However the races were exciting. The competition fierce. Why does that make it a joke?