Final Verdict ... Fog Is A Fraud

[Rupert Pupkin]

Originally Posted by dalakhani

so basically you are saying that competition and race set up have no impact on performance?

No, I didn't say that. Sometimes it has an impact and sometimes it doesn't. For example, you may see a horse break his maiden first-time out by 4 lengths. In his next start, he runs in a stakes against some a much stronger field and he wins by 5 lengths. I've seen that happen many times. So in that example, the stronger competition did not have an effect on the horse's performances. He stepped up against stronger competition and he ran just as good if not better. So in that case, the competition had no impact on his performance.
Sometimes the opposite happens. Maybe a horse wins easily first-time out and goes wire to wire. Let's say he runs the half-mile in :45 2/5 and gets an easy lead and he wins easily. In his next start, he runs in a stakes race against much better horses where the half is run in :44 1/5. He's not as goos as these horses and he can't run early with them and he gets beat. In this case, the competition and the race set up had a huge impact on performance.
Plenty of horses win by 3 lengths first-time out. I think you need to have a good eye to determine which of these horses are stars and which ones are not. I don't think that simply looking at the fractions or the speed figures will give you this information. You need to have a good eye.