Question re: Sky Mesa

[Betsy]

Ok, I'm having a disagreement at Thoroughbred Champions. We were discussing Pulpit and his sons as sires and I said (and I adore Pulpit) that Sky Mesa is mediocre at best (well, that's the essence of what I said). Others think he's a bargain and they started listing some of his stakes horses (which anyone can do with any sire). I can't think of one really top-class horse that Sky Mesa has sired, but those folks seem to think breeders love him and for a reason.

Am I wrong? Thanks!