How is this possible?

[RockHardTen1985]

TOP DIRT PERFORMERS 1. Quality Road (US) Metropolitan Handicap
130
2. Rachel Alexandra (US)
Fleur De Lis Handicap 124
Super Saver (US)
Kentucky Derby 124
4. Eskendereya (US) Fountain Of Youth 123
Espoir City (JAP)
February Stakes
123
Zenyatta (US)
Apple Blossom 123
7. Blame (US)
Stephen Foster Handicap 122
8. Lookin At Lucky (US)
Preakness 121
9. Battle Plan (US)
Stephen Foster Handicap 120
Big Drama (US)
Smile Sprint 120
Blind Luck (US)
Kentucky Oaks 120
Musket Man (US) Carter Handicap 120

How does Musket Man make this list for the Carter? Warriors Reward beat him.

[Scav]

Originally Posted by RockHardTen1985

TOP DIRT PERFORMERS 1. Quality Road (US) Metropolitan Handicap
130
2. Rachel Alexandra (US)
Fleur De Lis Handicap 124
Super Saver (US)
Kentucky Derby 124
4. Eskendereya (US) Fountain Of Youth 123
Espoir City (JAP)
February Stakes
123
Zenyatta (US)
Apple Blossom 123
7. Blame (US)
Stephen Foster Handicap 122
8. Lookin At Lucky (US)
Preakness 121
9. Battle Plan (US)
Stephen Foster Handicap 120
Big Drama (US)
Smile Sprint 120
Blind Luck (US)
Kentucky Oaks 120
Musket Man (US) Carter Handicap 120

How does Musket Man make this list for the Carter? Warriors Reward beat him.

JustinDew had to do the list

[RockHardTen1985]

Originally Posted by Scav

JustinDew had to do the list

This could explain, but I was being serious. I dont understand and would appreciate if someone would explain.

[3kings]

Where is the list from?

[RockHardTen1985]

Originally Posted by 3kings

Where is the list from?

Racing Post.

[RockHardTen1985]

Here would be my list for top dirt runners in the USA. Not based on who I like and what I think, because like I have said before IMO Z would be Rachel 9/10 times on dirt.

1. Quality Road--- CLEAR CUT #1
2. Eskendereya
3. Blame
4. Rachel
5. Zenyatta
6. Warriors Reward
7. Musket Man
8. Redding Colliery
9. Lookin at Lucky
10. Super Saver

[Scav]

Originally Posted by RockHardTen1985

Racing Post.

You think they care about American racing?

Maybe 3 times a year

[brockguy]

Originally Posted by RockHardTen1985

How does Musket Man make this list for the Carter? Warriors Reward beat him.

Musket Man lost by a nose giving Warriors Reward 2 pounds hence him being on the list and the winner not. Easy

That's they way they do things - they take weight pretty seriously

[RockHardTen1985]

Originally Posted by brockguy

Musket Man lost by a nose giving Warriors Reward 2 pounds hence him being on the list and the winner not. Easy

That's they way they do things - they take weight pretty seriously

Thanks Brock, can you explain the entire thing or post a link? 2 pounds is not much, and Warrior was wide, very wide around the turn, at this time Ramon was tripping out on Musket Man. Warrior is also 2/3 H2H vs Musket Man and was given possibly the WORSE RIDE OF THE YEAR IN THE MET MILE. Never have I witnessed such a tragedy then that of Calvin in the Met engaging Quality Road so early like that, it was a disaster.

[Danzig]

Originally Posted by Scav

JustinDew had to do the list

or drf voters.

[Danzig]

Originally Posted by RockHardTen1985

Here would be my list for top dirt runners in the USA. Not based on who I like and what I think, because like I have said before IMO Z would be Rachel 9/10 times on dirt.

1. Quality Road--- CLEAR CUT #1
2. Eskendereya
3. Blame
4. Rachel
5. Zenyatta
6. Warriors Reward
7. Musket Man
8. Redding Colliery
9. Lookin at Lucky
10. Super Saver

i believe they list them according to an individual performance. based on all racing this year, you think the apple blossom was a top ten dirt race? and you're taking racingpost to task??

[brockguy]

Originally Posted by RockHardTen1985

Thanks Brock, can you explain the entire thing or post a link? 2 pounds is not much, and Warrior was wide, very wide around the turn, at this time Ramon was tripping out on Musket Man. Warrior is also 2/3 H2H vs Musket Man and was given possibly the WORSE RIDE OF THE YEAR IN THE MET MILE. Never have I witnessed such a tragedy then that of Calvin in the Met engaging Quality Road so early like that, it was a disaster.

sorry man, what do you want explained? I know RPR wouldnt take trips into account.