Quote:
|
Originally Posted by declansharbor
Do you think if he accrued those numbers as an outfielder, he'd be the lock to get in that people say he is now? I think the reason he is getting in is because his offensive stats (17 years of em) blow away the HOF's that played 2nd base.
I wouldnt vote him in. Good thing I don't get a vote.
|
Why would you compare an outfielder to a 2nd baseman? You should be comparing him to other 2nd baseman of his generation and historically. On that he is a cinch to get in. Using your argument no shortstop other than Honus Wagner would be in and virtually no 2nd basemen.