Who Should Be the Five Heisman Finalists?
 

In my opinion and in no particular order:

Spiller

gerhart

Ingram

Tebow

Suh

Ingram should be Heisman and Bama should be National Champs soon. They are good!

I wouldnt have a problem with Ingram. He is some kind of back and will be a wonderful pro.

You have to love spiller though. That guy is simply amazing.

Gerhart!

He should get extra points for being a white tailback.

If there were a black place kicker, he would get extra points for me for whatever award place kickers win.

if MI doesn't win, (Bama won't have the heisman jinx in the NCG) then i vote for gerhardt.
mccoy out played tebow all year. suh and spiller are an interesting twist.

lou groza (sp). i think the Bama KR (Leigh Tiffin) is a finalist. he was in the semi-finals, last i heard.

Seriously, the closest thing I've ever seen to a good white tailback is Robert Smith.

LOL. John Riggins?

gerhardt is an old school bulldozer. he can run, block and catch passes. he'd look great in black and gold!

technically a fullback.:o

Also before my time.

Robert Smith that was on the Vikings? I think he was 1/2 black.

NT

Clearly the DT from Nebraska is the best player in college football. That wont win him the Heisman but he looks like the closest thing to Reggie White that I have seen. How freakin strong is that guy?

Paul Hornung

sad thing, no one has seen him outside the big12.

Hence the "closest thing" crack.

Jim Kiick

Craig James

Red Grange.

There was a corner back that use to play for the skins named Brian Davis who was white.

How many white corner backs can you name?

Jason Sehorn was always vastly overrated because he was white.

That one on side kick return defined his career

that..and marrying what's her name

Spiller, Gerhart and Ingram should be the only three in NY .

Come on Dala, surely you were a Mark van Eeghen fan:tro: :tro:

Certainly Byk is?

Seriously, the last good white tb in college was probably...Blake ezor?(sp?)

Ingram (winner)
Suh (runner up- would draft him in a heartbeat)
Spiller
Pike
Tebow

Ingram
Gerhart
Suh
Spiller
Moore

you need to sit and watch old Alabama, texas and oklahoma run the wishbone and Hammer people! a thing of beauty.:)

Ingram (winner)
Suh - should be the best pro
Gerhart
Tebow
McCoy

http://blogs.mercurynews.com/college...s-a-finalists/

Ingram, Tebow, McCoy, Suh and Gerhart. Kinda BS that Spiller got snubbed for Tebow, but I guess they needed the ratings.

Its a joke that Spiller did not get invited. He was the most electrifying player in College Football this year.

IMO, tebow has no business there this year but he's a Sr. and past winner. honestly, i won't be all that shocked if he wins again. the media lovefest with st. timmy continues.

He has no shot after this past weekend.

Ingram should win.. though Suh is the best player and the white boy RB is pretty darn good too!

As a Mizzou alum and fan, I'm obviously biased, but I think Danario Alexander deserves to be in New York ahead of Tebow.
People who didn't see the Tigers much this year probably don't realize that Alexander totally dominated the Big 12, and (I think) finished 1st in the country in receiving yards. I'm not saying he deserves to win, but he should be top five over Tebow.

had tebow not been a past winner, he wouldn't be on the list at all.

sorry, if anyone other than st. timmy should be in ny it's spiller from clemson.

ain't that the truth!