Secretariat, Big Brown and Man O'War
 

Who wins?

Better yet, we'll have a series of three 1 1/4 mile races. One on dirt, one on grass, and one on synthetic.

What are the results!

I say Man O'War dirt, Big Brown on turf (he was undefeated on the stuff!), and Secretariat, just to be fair, on the synthetic.

Obviously Big Brown would win on any surface.

And Curlin, in turn, would beat them all. Followed closely by Smarty Jones and Afleet Alex.

The fact that I know you, should really preclude me from laughing when I read some of your posts -- but it doesn't. LOL.

Eric

Secretariat wins this by a length over Man O war with Big Brown with a big fat CNF (Could not finish) in the result charts.

And, Nashoba's Key would have crushed them all.

I think you are sorely underestimating Rockport Harbor.

He would need to see the pps first.

Reading some of this drivel reminds me of the night at Siro's when that guy invited himself to our table.

ROTFL :D :zz:

I'm not sure he would win....but I know he would be favored.

Think , Secretariat would of buried them all. No disrepect to Man o'war.

None taken.

Casino Drive
 

he must still eligble for some non winners what ever So Cal 4 hoss field non bettable race. Thank God for NY racing !

Umm, actually, to some extent I could see this as fun. Yes, it's always an exercise in futility to have hypothetical races between horses from different eras. Fun as it might be -- there was nothing, absolutely nothing, fun about that guy inviting himself to sit down with us. Plus, it was your table. Ironically, when he found that out, he wanted to sit there even more. LOL.

Eric

Funny Cide would crush them all!! Especially the 7 year old version of him. :)

The Gutsy Gelding is Da Bomb !

That's not fair. These are mere horses. She's a monster.

C'mon guys, be serious!!

It's not like I threw Giant's Causeway into the mix!

I'll be serious. Man O War and Big Brown will speed duel into 21 44 fractions, setting it up for Secretariat.

On synthetic?

you guys forgot smooth air. i mean...fitness-wise, he's all over that field.

Peppers Pride would absolutely crush these.

Seriiously now,,,,,,,Big Red wins and its not even a discussion.

he would destroy big brown on any surface, at any distance, before ppl say things about me, does anyone really disagree with that ? ?

I don't know who would win a matchup of all time greats, but Perfect Drift would finish second.

nope, gotta agree with ya there.

Secretariat is the most overrated horse ever!!!

He's no White Tie.

I don't know if Smooth Air would beat them, but he would try really hard and almost certainly hit the board.

This discussion certainly shouldn't be had without Great Hunter.

Personally...I think Spooky Mulder would outgame them all:tro:

I dont get it ? Is any of this supposed to be funny ? Ppl sitting here naming shitty horse after shitty horse....
Lets talk about a race Thursday where we can all make money !!!!
Silver Stetson Man is the lock of the Aqueduct meet on thursday, and you might get a price on him with Songster and the Jerkens horse in there.

Is Master David entered in there? If not, I don't care.

No but we should not joke about Master David, I am not even sure that horse is still alive.

Yes, the Santa Anita 6 wide bias will be there

You are 100% right about that.
Master David is the AIDS of the horse racing humor industry.
Humorists can try as hard as they want, but you just can't get people to laugh at Master David jokes.