Will Todd fall with his 32 nominees this year
 

Scatt Daddy might be his best runner now, but that always finds a way to change. Todd=Derby jinks?? Maybe this year. I think I have said this for 6-7 years now
:eek:

Scat Daddy definitely isn't his best runner....

what 2year old did better?

minfield ..ect ect

I would say that Any Given Saturday and Circular Quay are more highly regarded as of this year.

Circular Quay is closer, the winner of the Hopeful and runner-up in the Breeders' Cup Juvenile

None are graded

Did better and is better are two different things at this point.

Poven, and unproven are 2 different things too

Scat Daddy is MY favorite of Pletcher's horses, but I would say that the two I mentioned are more highly touted right now.

Good morning OG.

I've no idea yet, but when I was sifting through over 100 pages of Bris pps looking at horses on the Derby Trail, it is amazing when one sees on paper how vast this man's stable is. How he manages to burn 'em up prior to the first Saturday in May, year after year, is mindboggling. He could possibly be changing his strategy though because Our Sacred Honor didn't run a lick yesterday in the Southwest.

Maybe he'll have half a dozen make it into the gate this year.

Wonder what the odds on that one would be?

The only thing Scat Daddy has been proving is he's not very good.

Top 25 of Daily Racing Form's 2007 Derby Watch finds Pletcher with six runners on the list, including three of the top five.

But he did this before
:confused:

Maybe they will sell him to a partnership
;)

Ravel.

Scat Daddy is very low on the list of current actual probables.

can't argue about his Negatives. 2 turns, big problem.

But did handle a mile

i thought ravel looked very good the other day.

Making Pletcher look pretty smart for selling his shares in Scat Daddy last year:rolleyes:


-bt-

After he made over 500K first at 2

:rolleyes:

It's a mute point. Nobody is going to beat Nobiz, plubCornelio is riding his arse off. Notional is his closest challenge.

Pretty BOLD statement being made for the 3rd week of Feb. (a lot can happen in 2 months)
Regardless of Cornelio riding his ass off, he's never won a derby
But if your statement turns out to be true i hope you got him at 8-1 or better in the furtures b/c he's not gonna be anywhere near that on Derby Day


-bt-

Daddy passed Nobiz in that one turn mile, after stalking. Passed and weaved through traffic like a buz saw.

I have a buddy who always says "the point is mute", but I can't hear him.....

You mean that one-turn Grade 1 Champange?? I think NoBiz turned a pretty good effort for his 2nd lifetime start. He clearly turned the tables on Scat Daddy last time out at Gulfstream.

I'm telling you guys, I thought if Drums of Thunder would break cleanly then he would upset Nobiz in the HB. Turns out it didn't matter, Nobiz ran away from him like Reggie Bush did to Urlacher. The Colt is special.

But if Rick Springfield had elected to use "mute" it would have actually rhymed with "cute."

But I feel so dirty when they start talking cute
I want to tell her that I love her but I can't cause I'm a mute.

You still listen to that on cassette?

I think Ravel is his best. I also like Any Given Saturday.

Daddy isn't a good front runner, or head to head. He is a stalker. Considering he ran head to head, didn't run bad. The race was a good learning one. Needs to sit off the pace setters to make a bid.

SD certainly could have worked out a better trip.

For sure, and he left plenty in the tank. 1st start since the cup, so he might be looking to breath hard. Who wants a horse to peek now anyway

You guys keep making excuses for these colts you seem to be emotionally attached to, there's nothing wrong with that but it doesn't help you at the betting window. Just think about the past Derby winners and how dominant they were - Smarty, Barbaro, Afleet Alex(he should have won the TC). Nobody made any excuses for these horses, they went out and dominated the field. I don't see that from Scat Daddy or Circular Quay. The jury is still out on Ravel and AG Sunday.

Attached? I never fall in love.

You don't want a horse to peek now, run lights out. If Tagg doesn't send out BIZ at the Youth, he didn't come back to good. These warm ups are to get the bankroll up. You don't need to win every race, to win the derby bumpercar event

Well, it's hard to make excuses for horses who have never lost leading up to the Derby(Smarty & Barbaro). AA, of course, didn't win the derby, and did have an excuse when he ran up the track at Oaklawn for one prep race. The jury is still out on every TC horse at this point.

The door is still open for a lot of colts, things will shake out after the 10th of March. If ScDy or CrQy can't win their next time out, and they will be up against tougher fields, their door will be closed. IMO.

Fortunately (or unfortunately, depending how you see it).. The door can't close on either SD or CQ (unless they get hurt) because both have enough graded earnings to get in the Derby already.

Interesting thread. You know, I can see being a fan of, or attached -- however, my commentary was strictly from a betting perspective. With that in mind -- how could you not dis-attach yourself in a nanosecond when you saw 1-9!

Even if you were a fan, and was rooting for this colt -- at 1-9 you absolutely could have and should have bet against him. Let him go off and make you look like an idiot, but that was the right play as far as I was concerned. Those are the horses you try to beat and beat more often than not.

Eric

....or take a pass and just sit back and watch the race.....

Yesterday's race at Oaklawn was one that demanded to be bet. Anytime you have a horse like Hard Spun taking over 60% of the money, when the best he possibly was was 30% to win, you must go in.

I bet, and I lost, but give me that scenerio five times a day and I'll make a fortune.

Agreed on the Southwest...a much deeper field than the Sam Davis. ( I thought Any Given Saturday was the 1-9/1-5 that ELA was referring to.)